Request A Quote
Please submit your contact information and a representative will be in touch with you as soon as possible.



Although we enjoy low staff turnover, we're always looking to grow and expand our team if an individual is the right fit for us. Steffey Hatoway employees enjoy a competitive benefits program, a relaxed work environment, incentive structures, and sometimes flexible working hours. We treat our staff as adults and give them the freedom to do their work and be creative. These things have helped solidify the great team we have in place currently.

Current Openings

Indianapolis Office:

Job Description

We are seeking an experienced insurance professional to join the Steffey Hatoway Personal Lines Team to serve as a Personal Lines Customer Service Representative.  This is an excellent opportunity to join a growing, friendly work environment.

Steffey Hatoway Insurance is an independent insurance agency which provides insurance solutions for businesses and individuals.  We have operated in Indiana for over 40 years and currently serve over 10,000 customers in 10 different states.

We provide an excellent benefit package for our employees and provide a culture that is both enriching and rewarding.  We value our employees and provide many opportunities throughout the year to reward our team of great staff. These include, but are not limited to: quarterly bonus shares, annual bonus shares, 401K match, disability insurance, paid time off, flexible hours, and more.

Position Responsibilities:

  • Manage client expectations
  • Communicate effectively during the quoting, renewal, and claims process.
  • Responsible for servicing a book of business efficiently; including policies, claims, quotes, endorsements and other service related activities.
  • Prioritize and manage workload to ensure efficient, timely, and accurate processing of transactions and other responsibilities.

Job Requirements

Minimum Qualifications:

  • Two (2) years Personal Insurance and other business-related experience and/or training; or equivalent combination of education and work experience.
  • IN Property & Casualty license achieved
  • Independent Insurance agency experience
  • Experience in Microsoft Office tools and Agency Management Systems

If you would like to apply, please fill out the form and below and upload your resume. We will be in touch with you shortly. Thanks!

Facebook IconInstagramInstagram