Request A Quote
Please submit your contact information and a representative will be in touch with you as soon as possible.



Serving the Midwest and parts of the Atlantic Coast, we can provide you with the service you deserve in twelve states.


The city of brotherly love has played hosts to many firsts in U.S. History, but also the first Steffey Hatoway office outside of Indiana. We provide Philadelphia the peace of mind it deserves through quality insurance products at an affordable price.

Learn More

New Palestine

Located in Sugar Creek Township just a few miles outside of Indianapolis, Indiana, New Palestine is the quintessential Hoosier small-town. Full of hard working people exuding Hoosier hospitality, we strive to embody this in our agency.

Learn More


Greenfield is the county seat and largest city in Hancock County, Indiana. Our Greenfield office has a strong staff in place who love Greenfield and the surrounding area.

Learn More


With a skyline as unique as its chili, Steffey Hatoway Insurance is proud to serve the Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky areas. We provide quality service and the small town business feel that you know and love.

Learn More


Steffey Hatoway Insurance has served the Indianapolis area for over thirty years. With thousands of clients in and around the Indianapolis area, we are proud to represent the Crossroads of America.

Learn More
Facebook IconInstagramInstagram