Indianapolis
Steffey Insurance has served the Indianapolis area for over thirty years. With thousands of clients in and around the Indianapolis area, we are proud to represent the Crossroads of America.

Our Locations
Located at Keystone at the Crossing, Steffey Insurance is in the heart of the Indianapolis north side.
Our Company
We have agents and customer service representatives for both personal and commercial insurance to make sure you get the timely service and insurance knowledge you deserve.


Personal Insurance
As an independent agent, we represent several insurance carriers. Whether it be home, auto, umbrella, boat, RV, or insurance for rental properties, we have solutions to make sure you have the best coverage at the best price.
Business Insurance
We have solutions for your business no matter how big or small. Business insurance can be complicated, so let us take the confusion out of it to make sure your business is covered at the right price with the service you deserve.

Indianapolis Office
9100 Keystone Xing Suite 510
Indianapolis, IN 46240
1-317-334-3743
OUR INDIANAPOLIS TEAM

MIKE STEFFEY
Principal Agent

MILLIE STEFFEY
Principal Agent

TRAVIS ROUND
Licensed Agent

THOMAS BROWNING
Licensed Agent

KAITLIN MCKERROW
Customer Service Representative

VALERIE ROBINSON
Customer Service Representative