Request A Quote
Please submit your contact information and a representative will be in touch with you as soon as possible.

An Indianapolis Based Company Auto • Home • Business • Life • Health Learn More Serving Philadelphia, PA Learn More Now Serving Cincinnati, OH Learn More Insuring Throughout the United States Learn More

Contact us today!

Please send a brief contact form our way and a licensed agent will contact you as soon as possible. Any details or special circumstances you can leave are greatly appreciated as well. We thank you in advance for the opportunity!

Video Du Jour

Sometimes daily, sometimes monthly, we'll update this section with a new video we think will be useful for our clients and site visitors. This content may be produced by ourselves, one of our trusted carriers, or just a YouTube All-Star. Enjoy!

Our Dedicated Services

Listed below are several of our most common product offerings. We have many companies with a wide range of insurance options, so please ask if you're uncertain of our ability to insure you. Chances are, we can!

Auto Insurance

Liability, comprehensive and collision. Contact us to make sure you have the coverages you need.

Homeowners Insurance

Protecting your largest asset can be complicated, let us help you find the policy that fits your needs

Business Insurance

Each business is different, and requires different types of insurance. No matter how small or large, our knowledgeable staff will find solutions to help protect your business


An umbrella, or Personal Catastrophe Liability, policy provides additional protection beyond your current insurance policy limits

Life Insurance

Life insurance can add an additional piece of mind to you and your family

Health Insurance

With the rising costs of healthcare, health insurance is as important as ever to protect you financially

Specialized Risk Appetite

Being in insurance for over 40 years allows you to develop niche markets along the way. These are just a few of the classes of business we specialize in today on a regional, or even national level.

Real Estate
Food & Beverage
  • Real Estate

    We specialize in all forms of real estate including: apartments, condo associations, HOA’s, office buildings, REIT’s, student housing, and senior living facilities.
    Learn More
  • a


    Whether it’s a software development company, app development, or cyber security firm, we’ve got you covered. We understand the nuances of these coverage options and how they affect your bottom line.
    Read More
  • a

    Surety Bonding

    We offer a full suite of surety options including an instant issue surety portal found on our website homepage. Beyond this, we offer contract surety and fidelity solutions for all project levels.
    Read More
  • Flood Insurance

    We provide both private market flood insurance, as well as FEMA programs throughout the country. We have access to private flood markets not available to many agents.
    Read More
  • Restaurants, Bars, Breweries, BYOB’s

    We enjoy insuring new restaurants and bars almost as much as we enjoy frequenting them. We can educate you in the coverages you require while offering the most competitive prices from a large lineup of insurance companies. We’ve also began writing BYOB’s with their strong growth in popularity over the recent years.
    Read More
  • Reverse Flow Business

    For international companies, setting up US subsidiaries can be daunting, especially when it comes to insurance. Fortunately, we have experience in assisting foreign companies with their insurance needs in the US. We work with several companies from the UK and Ireland currently.
    Read More

Our Blog

From time to time, we write. This blog will usually contain content that we think you'll find interesting and potentially answer any frequently asked questions.

Hear From Our Clients

"When going through my checklist of things that I needed, renter’s insurance was at the top of my list. I wanted to be sure that I was covered in the case that something was to happen to my apartment or any of my belongings. In conversation with Thomas, he provided me a quote within just a few minutes. Not only was my quote affordable, but he was very knowledgeable about the policy, consulted me through the process and provided valuable information about my deductible and overall coverage. Payment options are very flexible and I highly recommend contacting Thomas at Steffey Hatoway Insurance for any of your insurance needs. "

– Sydney S.

“No questions are ever left unanswered. Calls back are immediate and the staff is wonderful. Rates are always competitive and you really get the feeling they are looking out for your best interests.”

Chadwick E.

“It was an absolute pleasure working with Aaron and the Philly Agency. We first moved to Philadelphia and knew no one. Aaron was able to navigate all of the nuances of the local market and set us up with a home and auto policy tailored to our needs. We will be expanding coverage with an umbrella policy, and plan to continue working with Aaron for years to come! The best!”

Chris K.

“I’ve had the pleasure of working with Aaron Steffey on the recent purchase of home and automobile insurance coverage. Aaron was responsive, knowledgeable, and was able to provide a new insurance package at a substantial savings over my prior insurer. Aaron worked tirelessly to find the right insurance plan for my needs, and walked me through every step of the process. Aaron was particularly helpful in recognizing specialty risk needs and in scouring the market to find the right product. I am quite pleased with The Philly Agency’s work, and Aaron in particular, and they have earned a customer for life.”

E. Caplan

“I heard great things about Steffey insurance from several other customers, as well as employees that I am acquainted with. When I received a quote from Aaron, they were very competitive, if not the lowest quote I had received.”

Nathan M.

"I have been a customer of Mike Steffery since 1986. I have NEVER been disappointed with the quality of service or level of professionalism exhibited by he and his staff. You CAN TRUST these folks to do the right thing and make sure you are taken care of. I have lived in South Bend since 2001, but retain Steffey as my agent – because I appreciate their level of service."

A Google User

Areas We Serve

Serving the Midwest and parts of the Atlantic Coast, we can provide you with the service you deserve in twelve states.

With offices in Indiana, Pennsylvania and Ohio, Steffey Insurance is proud to have a regional presence with national licensing. As an independent insurance agency, we can quote you with several carriers to make sure you are getting our best rate no matter where you live.


Get In Touch! Stay Connected!

We like to hear from you. Please never hesitate to contact us regarding anything insurance related. We always want to be a click or call away from guiding you through any situation.

Contact Us

Fill out our simple quote form.

An agent will contact you shortly to discuss your needs in greater detail and provide you with quotes from all of our major insurance carriers.

¿Surety Bond?

Facebook IconInstagramInstagram